515 Niagara St. Welland, ON Tel: 905-732-2418


Whether you are seeking to change insurers or bought a car for the first time, full disclosure from the start will prevent any risk of misrepresentation if you do need to make a claim in the future. Select a quote type below!

instant effortless


Your home should be insured from the moment you take legal ownership and your broker’s expertise is particularly useful at this stage when you really need to match policy features with needs. Select a quote type below!

instant effortless


Anyone operating a business needs commercial insurance as part of an overall risk management strategy.



Personal umbrella liability coverage is not just for the corporate executive- It should form an important part of your insurance program.



Are you on track to achieve the goals and plans you and your family have made?



With our short boating season, no one
wants to miss any part of it trying to resolve an insurance-related misunderstanding.





Reuter & Reilly Insurance is proud to carry on the tradition of service excellence in the Niagara Peninsula for over 85 years. Our mission is to present our clients with a broad choice of insurance products and services in a professional, knowledgeable and friendly manner. Our Welland based, full service insurance brokerage offers clients a wide range of insurance solutions including: home & auto insurance, marine, commercial insurance, life insurance, disability and group benefits.

Read more


Please explore our website and check back often for more tips, advice, resources and discussions of interest. And of course, if you would ever like to speak to a broker, be sure to give our office a call at 905-732-2418.

We will work with you to ensure you fully understand your options and make sound insurance decisions.

Jeff Reuter, B.Comm., CAIB, CPIB
Reuter & Reilly Insurance Brokers


I’m officially switched over and so is my mother! My primary reason for leaving the other company after 25 years was because we were not treated very well. I feel like I have to tell you that we LOVE Jon! He has been wonderful! He’s great at dealing with my “older” mother. He’s been fantastic! He explains everything! He’s easy to talk to! It doesn’t make us feel dumb! I’m so glad we met Jon! He’s awesome!

Lynne. O

Lynne. O
R&R Insurance Client

I will for sure in the future, continue to spread the good word to friends and family. For years now we have received the best customer service from Reuter & Reilly and are grateful.

Patty F

Patty F
R&R Insurance Client

At Reuter & Reilly Insurance Brokers, we’ve got you covered.