515 Niagara St. Welland, ON Tel: 905-732-2418


Our team, who are ready to serve you!

Image description

Jeff Reuter

RIBO, B.Comm, CAIB, CPIB President

Jeff is the brokerage owner and has been in the business since 1995. After graduating from Notre Dame College School, he obtained his Bachelor of Commerce degree from McMaster University. Believing in continuing education he has earned his Canadian Accredited Insurance Broker certificate and Canadian Professional Insurance Broker certification.

Image description

Teresa Liota

RIBO, Inside Sales

Teresa has been with Reuter & Reilly Insurance since 1999 and is a valuable member of our team. Teresa is responsible for quoting all new personal lines and home and auto insurance policies. She resides with her family in Welland.

Image description

Barbara Brown

RIBO, Customer Service Representative

Barbara has been with Reuter & Reilly since 1987. She helps provide the stability that our brokerage is known for. Barbara is responsible for Personal Insurance Customer Service. She resides with her family in Port Colborne.

Image description

Steve Pinegar

Financial Services

Steve has his Life License and Mutual Funds license and is responsible for that end of our business. He enables us to offer a full compliment of insurance and investment products. Steve is a native of Chippawa.

Image description

Brittany Wilshire

RIBO, Customer Service Representative

Brittany provides excellent customer service to our Personal Insurance clients.  She has a keen interest in dealing with people and finding solutions to your insurance needs.  Brittany was raised in Port Colborne and still resides there with her family.

Image description

Jennifer Lea

Commercial Account Manager

Jennifer handles all of our Commercial accounts in a very detailed manner. She ensures that each account is reviewed and that client requirements are met. After a brief stint away from the Niagara Region, she now resides with her husband in Port Robinson. Eager to learn as much as possible, Jen has completed her Canadian Accredited Insurance Broker diploma.

Image description

Wendy Ashby

Wendy applies years of experience in the insurance industry to her administration role at Reuter & Reilly Insurance.  Wendy is a native of St. Catharines where she lives with her husband.  Wendy is the smiling voice that greets you by phone or in person when you enter our office.

At Reuter & Reilly Insurance Brokers, we’ve got you covered.